Cook Out vs Shake Shack: Burgers, Shakes, Fries and Value
Published November 19, 2026
Premium fast-casual counter service versus a late-night tray lane — both sell burgers and shakes, but the ticket shape is completely different.
Custard treat vs shake variety
Shake Shack is the stop when a ShackBurger, cheese fries and a custard Concrete are the plan and you want to sit a minute.
Cook Out is the stop when two sides, dozens of shake flavors and a drive-thru after midnight matter more than table service.
Prices last checked July 31, 2026. May vary by location — check your local Cook Out.
Unofficial; not official Cook Out pricing. Price methodology
Cook Out vs Shake Shack comes down to two very different ideas of a great burger-and-shake run. Cook Out is a Southern drive-thru chain that sells char-grilled burgers inside cheap trays with two sides and a drink, stays open late and offers dozens of milkshake flavors. Shake Shack is a New York-born premium fast-casual counter that serves Angus beef cheeseburgers on potato buns, crinkle-cut fries and shakes made from its own frozen custard. This guide compares the burgers, shakes, fries, hot dogs, chicken, hours, ordering and value so you know which one fits tonight.
This is an unofficial fan guide. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Cook Out or Shake Shack. Menus, hours and prices vary by location, so check your local store.
Cook Out vs Shake Shack at a glance
| Cook Out | Shake Shack | |
|---|---|---|
| Started | 1989, Greensboro, North Carolina | Hot dog cart in 2001; first Shake Shack in July 2004, Madison Square Park, New York City |
| Ownership | Private, family-run, company-operated | Public company (NYSE: SHAK), founded by restaurateur Danny Meyer |
| Format | Drive-thru first, trays and combos | Counter service, kiosks and app |
| Burger style | Char-grilled, ordered by "style" | Griddled Angus beef cheeseburgers on potato buns |
| Shakes | Fancy Milkshakes, about 39 flavors, one big size | Hand-spun frozen custard shakes and Concretes |
| Fries | Regular or Cajun, one side among many | Crinkle-cut, plain or loaded |
| Typical hours | Late night, often until 3 or 4 AM | Varies by location |
| Best for | Cheap full meals, late runs, shake variety | A premium burger, custard and a sit-down break |
In short, Cook Out is built for a cheap, filling meal any time of night, and Shake Shack for a more polished, higher-priced treat.
A short history of each
Cook Out opened in Greensboro, North Carolina, in 1989 and is still a private, family-run company that operates its own restaurants. Our Cook Out history page tells the full story.
Shake Shack started as a hot dog cart in New York City's Madison Square Park in 2001, run as part of a park renewal effort backed by restaurateur Danny Meyer. In July 2004 it opened a permanent kiosk in the park with burgers, hot dogs, fries and its namesake shakes. It became a public company in 2015 and now has locations across the United States and abroad, including in many Southern cities where Cook Out also operates.
The burgers
Cook Out: char-grilled and sold by style
Cook Out burgers are cooked on a char-grill, and you usually order them by "style" rather than picking every topping. Cook Out Style comes with chili, slaw, mustard and onions. Original is the lettuce, tomato, pickle and mayo classic. Cheddar Style adds melted cheddar, and Out West brings BBQ sauce, bacon and cheese. Our Cook Out burger styles explained guide covers every option.
Size is easy to scale. The Regular burger is a quarter pound, the Big Double stacks two patties, and the Huge Burger is the larger single option. See the whole Cook Out burgers menu for the full lineup.
Shake Shack: Angus beef on a potato bun
Shake Shack's signature is the ShackBurger, an Angus beef cheeseburger with lettuce, tomato and ShackSauce on a toasted potato bun. Its menu lists each patty at about 4 ounces before cooking, and the company says it uses 100% Angus beef with no added hormones or antibiotics. Upgrades include the SmokeShack, with applewood-smoked bacon, chopped cherry peppers and ShackSauce, and a bacon cheeseburger. For non-meat eaters, the 'Shroom Burger is a crisp-fried portobello mushroom filled with melted muenster and cheddar, and a Veggie Shack made with vegetables and grains is on many menus. Shake Shack also offers burgers in a lettuce wrap.
Which burger wins?
If you love a smoky char-grill flavor and a loaded Southern topping combo like chili and slaw, Cook Out wins. If you want a rich, griddled cheeseburger with a soft potato bun and a signature sauce, Shake Shack wins.
Milkshakes: Cook Out's flavors vs Shake Shack's custard
Cook Out's Fancy Milkshakes are hand-spun with real ice cream. Our Cook Out milkshake flavors page lists about 39 regular flavors, from Banana Pudding to Cheesecake, Cappuccino and Oreo, and every flavor comes in one large size of roughly 32 to 35 ounces. Most stores let you mix two flavors, and seasonal shakes rotate in, such as the eggnog milkshake around the holidays. You can also upgrade the drink in a tray to a shake for a small add-on. Try combinations with our Milkshake Mixer tool.
Shake Shack builds its shakes on house-made frozen custard. The core menu includes vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, OREO cookies and cream, coffee and black and white, plus limited-time shakes that change through the year. It also sells Concretes, which are dense frozen custard blended with mix-ins, along with cups and cones of plain custard.
Winner: Cook Out for variety and size, Shake Shack for a richer custard texture. If you love custard, our Cook Out vs Culver's comparison covers another custard favorite.
Fries and sides
Shake Shack's fries are crinkle-cut. You can order them plain, as cheese fries topped with melted cheddar and American cheese, or with bacon, and some menus add spicy or truffle versions.
Cook Out treats fries as one choice in a long list of tray sides. You can pick regular fries, Cajun fries, cheese fries, chili cheese fries, hush puppies, onion rings, a corn dog, chicken nuggets, a quesadilla and more, depending on the store. See the full Cook Out sides menu or our Cook Out sides ranked list.
Winner: Shake Shack if you love crinkle-cut fries with cheese sauce, Cook Out for sheer choice.
Hot dogs and chicken
Both chains sell hot dogs. Shake Shack uses 100% Vienna Beef hot dogs on toasted potato buns, with cheese, bacon or crispy onion versions. Cook Out char-grills its dogs and offers them several ways, including the Cook Out Style hot dog with homemade chili, slaw, mustard and onion. Browse the Cook Out hot dogs menu.
For chicken, Shake Shack's Chicken Shack is a hand-breaded, antibiotic-free white-meat chicken breast with lettuce, pickles and buttermilk herb mayo, and Chicken Bites come with dipping sauces. Cook Out has a wider chicken lineup, from spicy chicken sandwiches to chicken strips, wraps and Cajun chicken. Compare them in our Cook Out chicken sandwiches ranked post and the Cook Out chicken menu.
Drinks
Cook Out's drink list includes sweet tea, soft drinks and the Southern cherry soda Cheerwine, which you can also get as a Cheerwine float. Learn more in what is Cheerwine or see the Cook Out drinks menu.
Shake Shack is known for its Shack-made lemonade, flavored lemonades and organic iced tea, and many locations also serve beer and wine.
Price and value
This is where the gap is widest. A Cook Out tray bundles a main, two sides and a drink at a low price, so one order is a full meal. Shake Shack is priced as a premium fast-casual chain, so a burger, fries and a shake usually adds up to a noticeably bigger check.
We do not list Shake Shack prices because they change by city. For Cook Out, see the dated Cook Out menu prices, tray combos and the Tray Builder to plan a meal. Our Cook Out value comparison shows how Cook Out stacks up against other chains with real receipts.
Hours, ordering and delivery
Most Cook Out restaurants open at 10:30 AM and close at 3 AM Sunday through Thursday and 4 AM on Friday and Saturday, though Thanksgiving is a reduced-hours day. See Cook Out hours for details. Cook Out is drive-thru first and has no nationwide ordering app, and delivery depends on the store. Our Cook Out delivery guide explains where it works.
Shake Shack hours vary by location, so check the app or the store listing. You can order at the counter, at a kiosk in many stores, or ahead in the Shake Shack app for pickup (and delivery in many areas).
Allergens and dietary needs
Both menus use milk, wheat, egg and soy in many items. Shake Shack lists allergens for each menu item, and its lettuce-wrap burgers are labeled gluten-free, although it notes cross-contact can still happen. At Cook Out, read our Cook Out allergen menu, gluten-free options and plant-based ordering notes, and confirm in store. For lighter picks, see the healthiest Cook Out options or check numbers with the Cook Out calorie calculator.
Which should you choose?
Choose Cook Out if you:
- Want a full meal with two sides and a drink for a low price
- Are hungry late at night
- Want to try lots of milkshake flavors or mix two together
- Are feeding a group on a budget
Choose Shake Shack if you:
- Want a premium Angus cheeseburger
- Love frozen custard shakes and Concretes
- Want crinkle-cut cheese fries
- Prefer ordering from an app and sitting down to eat
Ordering tips for each
At Cook Out, start with a tray, make one side something special like hush puppies or a corn dog, and upgrade the drink to a shake. Our how to order at Cook Out guide and what to order at Cook Out list help first-timers.
At Shake Shack, start with a single ShackBurger if you are not very hungry, add cheese fries to share, and look for the limited-time shake or Concrete of the month.
The bottom line
Cook Out vs Shake Shack is value and variety against polish and custard. Cook Out gives you a char-grilled burger, two sides and dozens of shake flavors for a low price, often after midnight. Shake Shack gives you a premium Angus cheeseburger, crinkle-cut fries and a custard shake for more money. Want more burger matchups? Read Cook Out vs Five Guys and Cook Out vs Steak 'n Shake, or see the full Cook Out menu with prices.