Cook Out vs Culver's: Which Burger and Shake Stop Wins?
Published November 5, 2026
Quick Answer: Cook Out vs Culver's pits a Southern late-night drive-thru against a Midwest family favorite. Cook Out wins on value, with the Cook Out Tray (a main, two sides and a drink at one low price), late hours and about 39 thick milkshake flavors. Culver's wins on its ButterBurgers, cheese curds and Fresh Frozen Custard, with a new Flavor of the Day every day. If you want a cheap, filling meal late at night, choose Cook Out. If you want a sit-down family meal and the creamiest custard, choose Culver's.
Culver’s is the Midwest custard stop; Cook Out is the Southern tray stop. Overlap markets are growing but the default craving is still different.
Custard daypart vs shake upgrade
If the trip is about Fresh Frozen Custard and a Flavor of the Day, Culver’s is the destination. If the trip is about a tray drink upgraded to a thick shake, Cook Out is the habit.
Family dine-in and curbside culture fits Culver’s. Double drive-thru and walk-up windows fit Cook Out.
Prices last checked July 31, 2026. May vary by location — check your local Cook Out.
Unofficial; not official Cook Out pricing. Price methodology
This site is an unofficial fan guide and is not affiliated with Cook Out or Culver's. Prices are typical menu-board prices and vary by location.
Quick comparison
| Cook Out | Culver's | |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | 1989, Greensboro, NC (see our history page) | Midwest chain (Culver's corporate history) |
| Headquarters | Thomasville, North Carolina | Prairie du Sac, Wisconsin |
| Size | Regional Southeast U.S. chain (sourced counts on our history page) | National U.S. chain (Midwest-strong) |
| Signature item | Char-grilled burgers and the Cook Out Tray | ButterBurgers and Fresh Frozen Custard |
| Combo | Tray: main + 2 sides + drink | Value basket: main, side and drink |
| Dessert | About 39 milkshake flavors | Custard, Concrete Mixers, shakes, Flavor of the Day |
| Hours | Typically 10:30 AM to 3 or 4 AM | Usually late morning to late evening |
| Service | Drive-thru focused | Dining room and drive-thru |
The burgers
Cook Out burgers are char-grilled over an open flame, which gives them a smoky taste and grill marks. You choose a style: Cook Out Style comes with chili, slaw, mustard and onion; Cheddar Style adds melted cheddar; Out West Style has BBQ sauce, bacon and cheese. A Big Double gives you two patties. Our Cook Out burger styles guide explains them all.
Culver's is known for the ButterBurger. Fresh, never-frozen beef is seared on the grill after you order and served on a lightly buttered, toasted bun. The thin patties get crisp, browned edges. You can get single, double or triple patties and add toppings like cheese, bacon or mushrooms.
Verdict: It is a matter of taste. Cook Out for smoky char-grilled flavor; Culver's for crispy-edged, buttery burgers.
Value: Cook Out Tray vs Culver's value basket
Cook Out is hard to beat on price. A Regular Tray is typically around $7.39 and a Jr. Tray around $6.39, and both include a main, two sides and a drink. You can swap the drink for a milkshake for a small extra charge. See our tray and combo guide.
Culver's value baskets include a main, one side and a drink. They are priced higher than a Cook Out Tray in most markets, though portions are generous and the food is made to order.
Verdict: Cook Out for the most food for the least money.
Sides
Cook Out's long sides list includes fries, hushpuppies, onion rings, chicken nuggets, a corn dog, chili cheese fries and cheese bites. Two come with every tray. See our Cook Out sides menu.
Culver's sides include crinkle-cut fries, onion rings and its famous Cheese Curds: pieces of fresh yellow or white cheddar, breaded with herbs and spices and fried. Many fans say the curds alone are worth the visit.
Verdict: Cook Out for variety; Culver's for cheese curds.
Milkshakes vs frozen custard
This is the headline matchup.
Cook Out offers about 39 milkshake flavors, including banana pudding, cheesecake, Oreo, peach cobbler and many more. The shakes are thick, sweet and cheap. Browse them all on our milkshake menu.
Culver's makes Fresh Frozen Custard in small batches throughout the day. Custard is denser and creamier than regular soft-serve. Every Culver's has a Flavor of the Day, and you can get custard in a cup or cone, as a shake, or as a Concrete Mixer with toppings blended in.
Verdict: Cook Out for flavor variety and price; Culver's for richness and texture. Many people would call it a tie.
Chicken, fish and other mains
Cook Out has chicken sandwiches, chicken strips, BBQ sandwiches, hot dogs and quesadillas.
Culver's offers chicken tenders, grilled and crispy chicken sandwiches, North Atlantic Cod (popular on Fridays), salads and, at many locations, a soup of the day.
Verdict: Culver's for a broader sit-down menu; Cook Out for barbecue and hot dogs.
Kids and families
Culver's is built for families, with a dining room, Scoopie Kids' Meals that come with a small custard, and staff who often bring your order to your table. Cook Out is mainly a drive-thru, though trays are easy to order for everyone in the car.
Verdict: Culver's for a sit-down family meal; Cook Out for a quick family drive-thru.
Hours and late night
Cook Out is famous for late-night hours. Many locations stay open until 3 or 4 AM.
Culver's hours vary by location, but most restaurants open in the late morning and close in the evening. Check the Culver's locator for your nearest store.
Verdict: Cook Out for late nights.
Where you can find each
Cook Out is regional in the Southeast. Culver's is a larger Midwest-rooted chain that has expanded into parts of the South. Whether both brands appear near you depends on your town — check each chain's locator. Learn more about Cook Out's roots in our Cook Out history.
What to order at each
At Cook Out
- A Regular Tray with a Cook Out Style burger, hushpuppies and onion rings.
- A BBQ sandwich tray if you want a Southern classic.
- A milkshake swap in a flavor you cannot get elsewhere, such as banana pudding.
At Culver's
- A double ButterBurger with cheese.
- A side of Cheese Curds.
- A scoop or Concrete Mixer made with the Flavor of the Day.
If you are deciding for a group, Cook Out usually costs less and works for late nights, while Culver's is better for a relaxed sit-down meal with dessert.
How the food is made
The two chains take different approaches in the kitchen, and you can taste it.
Cook Out cooks its burgers over an open flame, which is unusual for a fast-food chain at its price. The char-grill gives the patties a smoky flavor and crisp edges, and the style toppings, like chili and slaw on Cook Out Style, are added after. The menu is built for speed: most orders come through the drive-thru, and double lanes at many stores keep lines moving, even late at night.
Culver's makes most items to order. Its fact sheet says ButterBurgers are seared on the grill after each guest orders, cheese curds are breaded with a signature blend of herbs and spices, and the North Atlantic Cod is hand-battered in the restaurant. Fresh Frozen Custard is made in small batches throughout the day. Because food is cooked to order, waits can be a little longer than at a typical drive-thru, which is one reason Culver's leans on its dining room.
Ordering tips
- At Cook Out, say the burger name and then the style at the speaker, such as "Big Double, Cook Out Style." Swap your drink for a shake to get dessert in the tray price plus a small upcharge.
- At Cook Out, bring an idea of your two sides before you reach the speaker. The list is long, and the line moves fast.
- At Culver's, check the Flavor of the Day before you go. Each restaurant posts its custard flavor calendar, and fans plan visits around favorite flavors.
- At Culver's, try a Concrete Mixer if you want toppings like cookie pieces or fruit blended into your custard.
- At both, ask about limited-time items. Seasonal shakes and custard flavors come and go.
Allergens and nutrition
Both chains publish nutrition and allergen information. Recipes, suppliers and menu items can change, so if you have an allergy, check with the restaurant before you order.
Which should you choose?
- Choose Cook Out if you want the cheapest filling meal, a char-grilled burger, two sides, dozens of shake flavors or a late-night stop.
- Choose Culver's if you want a ButterBurger, cheese curds, rich frozen custard, a sit-down family meal or a Friday fish dinner.
For another burger-and-shake matchup, see Cook Out vs In-N-Out.
Comparing another frozen-treat favorite? Read Cook Out vs Dairy Queen.
For more head-to-heads, see Cook Out vs Krystal, Cook Out vs McDonald's, Cook Out vs Burger King and our full Cook Out value comparison.
For another frozen-custard favorite, see how Cook Out compares with Shake Shack.