· Unofficial fan guide · Methodology
Cook Out milkshake flavors (2026)
About 39 hand-spun Fancy Milkshake flavors. Mix any two at no extra charge at most stores. Typical à la carte price about $3.99 — boards vary.
39 items · Verified July 31, 2026
Last verified: · Southeast locations (NC and neighboring states), verified July 2026
Unofficial; prices vary. Price methodology
The full flavor list is on this page — prices, sizes, and mix notes. Taste rankings live in a separate fan post. A tray drink upgrade is often about $1.60.
Photos are illustrative. Several flavors share a placeholder cup and are not official product shots.
Banana Berry
33.6 oz
Fancy Banana Berry milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Banana Pineapple
32 oz
Fancy Banana Pineapple milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Banana Pudding
Popular32.7 oz
Fancy Banana Pudding milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Blueberry
32.9 oz
Fancy Blueberry milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Cappuccino
31.9 oz
Fancy Cappuccino milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Caramel
33.5 oz
Fancy Caramel milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Cheesecake
Popular32.6 oz
Fancy Cheesecake milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Chocolate Cherry
32.1 oz
Fancy Chocolate Cherry milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Double Chocolate
33.6 oz
Fancy Double Chocolate milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Strawberry
32.8 oz
Fancy Strawberry milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Chocolate Malt
34.7 oz
Fancy Chocolate Malt milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Chocolate Chip Mint
Popular35 oz
Fancy Chocolate Chip Mint milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Fresh Banana
30.9 oz
Fancy Fresh Banana milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Fresh Eggnog
35 oz
Fancy Fresh Eggnog milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Heath Toffee
32.1 oz
Fancy Heath Toffee milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
M&M
32.6 oz
Fancy M&M milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Peach
32.7 oz
Fancy Peach milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Peach Cobbler
34.5 oz
Fancy Peach Cobbler milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Oreo Mint
Popular33 oz
Fancy Oreo Mint milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Orange Push-up
34 oz
Fancy Orange Push-up milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Peanut Butter Fudge
32.2 oz
Fancy Peanut Butter Fudge milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Peppermint
35 oz
Fancy Peppermint milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Pineapple
33 oz
Fancy Pineapple milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Cherry
32.3 oz
Fancy Cherry milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Reese's Cup
33.4 oz
Fancy Reese's Cup milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Snickers
32.4 oz
Fancy Snickers milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Vanilla
32.9 oz
Fancy Vanilla milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Walnut
33.1 oz
Fancy Walnut milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Chocolate Chip
34.6 oz
Fancy Chocolate Chip milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Banana Nut
32.1 oz
Fancy Banana Nut milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Banana Fudge
33.5 oz
Fancy Banana Fudge milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Fresh Watermelon
35 oz
Fancy Fresh Watermelon milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Chocolate Nut
33.4 oz
Fancy Chocolate Nut milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Fresh Peanut Butter
32.8 oz
Fancy Fresh Peanut Butter milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Hershey's Chocolate
32.9 oz
Fancy Hershey's Chocolate milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Mocha
35.3 oz
Fancy Mocha milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Caramel Fudge
32.8 oz
Fancy Caramel Fudge milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Peanut Butter Banana
32.8 oz
Fancy Peanut Butter Banana milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99
Oreo
Popular33 oz
Fancy Oreo milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.
$3.99