Guide updated October 2026 · Board prices checked July 31, 2026 · Unofficial fan guide · Methodology

Cook Out milkshake flavors (2026)

Q: How many milkshake flavors does Cook Out have?

Cook Out features 39 distinct Fancy Milkshake flavors made with real fresh ingredients. Popular picks include Oreo Mint, Banana Pudding, and seasonal Fresh Watermelon (July–August).

Q: What is the milkshakes price at Cook Out?

Standalone Fancy Milkshakes commonly run about $3.99 on Southeast boards we checked in July 2026. As a tray drink upgrade, many stores add about $1.60 . Local boards differ.

Q: What are the best milkshake flavor combinations?

Fan favorites: Banana Pudding + Cheesecake , Chocolate + Peanut Butter Fudge , Oreo Mint + Vanilla , and Strawberry + Fresh Banana . Ask for "half and half" to mix any two.

About 39 hand-spun Fancy Milkshake flavors. Mix any two at no extra charge at most stores. Typical à la carte price about $3.99 — boards vary.

39 items · Verified July 31, 2026

Last verified: July 31, 2026 · Southeast locations (NC and neighboring states), verified July 2026

Unofficial; prices vary. Price methodology

The full flavor list is on this page — prices, sizes, and mix notes. Taste rankings live in a separate fan post. A tray drink upgrade is often about $1.60.

Photos are illustrative. Several flavors share a placeholder cup and are not official product shots.

Wondering how big a Cook Out shake is? Every flavour comes in one size of about 32 to 35 oz.

Seasonal flavors such as Fresh Watermelon, pumpkin pie and eggnog rotate by store and month. See when the holiday shakes return.

Banana Berry

33.6 oz

Fancy Banana Berry milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Banana Pineapple

32 oz

Fancy Banana Pineapple milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Banana Pudding

Popular

32.7 oz

Fancy Banana Pudding milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Blueberry

32.9 oz

Fancy Blueberry milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Cappuccino

31.9 oz

Fancy Cappuccino milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Caramel

33.5 oz

Fancy Caramel milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Cheesecake

Popular

32.6 oz

Fancy Cheesecake milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Chocolate Cherry

32.1 oz

Fancy Chocolate Cherry milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Double Chocolate

33.6 oz

Fancy Double Chocolate milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Strawberry

32.8 oz

Fancy Strawberry milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Chocolate Malt

34.7 oz

Fancy Chocolate Malt milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Chocolate Chip Mint

Popular

35 oz

Fancy Chocolate Chip Mint milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Fresh Banana

30.9 oz

Fancy Fresh Banana milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Fresh Eggnog

35 oz

Fancy Fresh Eggnog milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Heath Toffee

32.1 oz

Fancy Heath Toffee milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

M&M

32.6 oz

Fancy M&M milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Peach

32.7 oz

Fancy Peach milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Peach Cobbler

34.5 oz

Fancy Peach Cobbler milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Oreo Mint

Popular

33 oz

Fancy Oreo Mint milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Orange Push-up

34 oz

Fancy Orange Push-up milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Peanut Butter Fudge

32.2 oz

Fancy Peanut Butter Fudge milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Peppermint

35 oz

Fancy Peppermint milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Pineapple

33 oz

Fancy Pineapple milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Cherry

32.3 oz

Fancy Cherry milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Reese's Cup

33.4 oz

Fancy Reese's Cup milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Snickers

32.4 oz

Fancy Snickers milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Vanilla

32.9 oz

Fancy Vanilla milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Walnut

33.1 oz

Fancy Walnut milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Chocolate Chip

34.6 oz

Fancy Chocolate Chip milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Banana Nut

32.1 oz

Fancy Banana Nut milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Banana Fudge

33.5 oz

Fancy Banana Fudge milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Fresh Watermelon

35 oz

Fancy Fresh Watermelon milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Chocolate Nut

33.4 oz

Fancy Chocolate Nut milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Fresh Peanut Butter

32.8 oz

Fancy Fresh Peanut Butter milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Hershey's Chocolate

32.9 oz

Fancy Hershey's Chocolate milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Mocha

35.3 oz

Fancy Mocha milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Caramel Fudge

32.8 oz

Fancy Caramel Fudge milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Peanut Butter Banana

32.8 oz

Fancy Peanut Butter Banana milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

Oreo

Popular

33 oz

Fancy Oreo milkshake — hand-spun with real ice cream.

$3.99

MilkShake Mixer →Tray Builder →Taste ranking (opinion) →Tray price →Desserts & Floats →

Frequently Asked Questions

How many milkshake flavors does Cook Out have?

Cook Out features 39 distinct Fancy Milkshake flavors made with real fresh ingredients. Popular picks include Oreo Mint, Banana Pudding, and seasonal Fresh Watermelon (July–August).

What is the milkshakes price at Cook Out?

Standalone Fancy Milkshakes commonly run about $3.99 on Southeast boards we checked in July 2026. As a tray drink upgrade, many stores add about $1.60. Local boards differ.

What are the best milkshake flavor combinations?

Fan favorites: Banana Pudding + Cheesecake, Chocolate + Peanut Butter Fudge, Oreo Mint + Vanilla, and Strawberry + Fresh Banana. Ask for "half and half" to mix any two.