Comparisons

Cook Out vs Five Guys: Burgers, Fries, Shakes and Value

Published November 17, 2026

Char-grilled burger tray with hush puppies and a thick milkshake beside a foil-wrapped two-patty cheeseburger and a paper cup of fresh-cut fries for a Cook Out vs Five Guys comparison

Better-burger indulgence and tray value often sit on the same strip — the question is whether you want one loaded sandwich or a full car meal.

Burger event vs burger meal

Five Guys is the pick when fresh-cut fries in the bag and a two-patty build are the point. Cook Out is the pick when two sides, a shake upgrade and a late lane matter more.

Peanut oil fries and in-shell peanuts define the Five Guys dining room. Hush puppies, Cheerwine and char-grill smoke define the Cook Out board.

Prices last checked July 31, 2026. May vary by location — check your local Cook Out.

Unofficial; not official Cook Out pricing. Price methodology

Cook Out vs Five Guys is one of the most common burger debates in the Southeast, because the two chains often sit a few miles apart and appeal to the same hungry crowd. Cook Out sells char-grilled burgers inside cheap trays with two sides and a drink, and it stays open late. Five Guys builds a bigger, fully customizable burger with a mountain of fresh-cut fries, and it charges more for it. This guide compares the burgers, fries, shakes, hours, ordering style and value so you can pick the right one for your appetite and your budget.

This is an unofficial fan guide. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Cook Out or Five Guys. Menus, hours and prices vary by location, so check your local store.

Cook Out vs Five Guys at a glance

Cook Out Five Guys
Founded 1989, Greensboro, North Carolina 1986, Arlington, Virginia
Ownership Private, family-run, company-operated Family-founded, franchised since 2003
Signature format The tray: main + 2 sides + drink Build-your-own burger + fries
Burger style Char-grilled, named "styles" Griddled, two patties standard
Toppings Set styles plus add-ons 15 free toppings
Fries Regular or Cajun, one of many sides Five Guys Style or Cajun, peanut oil
Shakes About 39 Fancy Milkshake flavors Vanilla base + free mix-ins
Typical hours Late night, often to 3 or 4 AM Lunch to evening (varies)
Best for Cheap full meals and late-night runs A big custom burger and fries

Both chains started as small family burger stands in the Mid-Atlantic and South, and both still lean on simple menus. The big difference is how they package a meal.

The burgers

Cook Out: char-grilled and sold by style

Cook Out burgers are cooked over a char-grill, and you order them by "style" rather than by building every topping yourself. The famous Cook Out Style comes with chili, slaw, mustard and onions, Original is the lettuce-tomato-pickle-mayo baseline, Cheddar Style adds melted cheddar and grilled onions, and Out West brings BBQ sauce, bacon and cheese. Our Cook Out burger styles explained guide breaks down every option.

Size is flexible too. The Regular is a quarter-pound burger, the Big Double stacks two patties, and the Huge Burger is the bigger single-burger option. Browse the full Cook Out burgers menu for prices at a typical store.

Five Guys: two patties and free toppings

At Five Guys, a standard Hamburger comes with two fresh beef patties on a toasted sesame bun. If you want one patty, you order the "Little" version. The draw is customization: Five Guys says it offers 15 free toppings, including grilled onions, grilled mushrooms, jalapeños, green peppers, relish and several sauces. Five Guys also suggests ready-made combinations such as "All The Way," which piles on grilled onions, grilled mushrooms, lettuce, pickles, tomatoes, ketchup, mustard and mayo.

The patties are cooked on a flat-top grill, and the company says the grills are seasoned only with the natural fat from the beef, not oil.

Which burger wins?

If you want a big, juicy, loaded burger and you do not mind paying more, Five Guys is built for that. If you like the smoky char-grill flavor and a set "style" that someone has already perfected, Cook Out wins, and you get far more food around the burger for the money. Many people simply decide based on whether they want a burger meal (Cook Out) or a burger event (Five Guys).

Fries and sides

This is where the two chains feel most different.

Five Guys is famous for its fries. It cuts fresh potatoes in store and fries them in 100% refined peanut oil, offered either Five Guys Style (lightly salted) or Cajun Style. Five Guys also says an extra scoop of fries comes standard, which is why a "regular" order often spills into the bag.

Cook Out treats fries as one side among many. A tray lets you choose two sides from a long list that includes fries, Cajun fries, chili cheese fries, hush puppies, onion rings, okra, chicken nuggets, a quesadilla, a corn dog and the walking taco at most stores. Some of those "sides" are really small mains, which is why a tray can feel like two meals in one. See the full Cook Out sides menu and our Cook Out sides ranked list for the best picks.

Winner: Five Guys for pure fries, Cook Out for variety.

Milkshakes

Both chains take shakes seriously, but in different ways.

Cook Out's Fancy Milkshakes are hand-spun with real ice cream, and our Cook Out milkshake flavors page lists about 39 regular flavors, from Banana Pudding to Cheesecake and Oreo. Most stores let you mix two flavors at no extra charge, and you can upgrade the drink in a tray to a milkshake for a small add-on. Try combinations with our Milkshake Mixer tool.

Five Guys starts every shake with a hand-spun vanilla base. You then add as many free mix-ins as you like, such as chocolate, strawberries, bananas, peanut butter, salted caramel, Oreo cookie pieces, coffee and even bacon, and finish with whipped cream.

Winner: Cook Out for flavor range and price, Five Guys for build-your-own mixing.

Price and value

Cook Out's whole menu is built around value. A tray bundles a main, two sides and a drink in one low price, which is hard for any burger chain to match. Five Guys is a "better burger" chain with a higher ticket, because the burger is larger, the toppings are unlimited and the fries portion is big.

We compared real receipts in our dated Cook Out vs Five Guys vs Wendy's value check, which also explains how we priced each meal. For current Cook Out numbers, use the full Cook Out price list and the tray combos guide. Prices change by state, so read our state price notes before you compare boards.

A fair way to think about it:

Hours and late-night food

Cook Out is a late-night favorite. According to our Cook Out hours guide, most locations open around 10:30 AM and stay open until about 3:00 AM Sunday through Thursday and 4:00 AM on Friday and Saturday, with a strong drive-thru focus.

Five Guys hours vary by restaurant. Many locations serve lunch and dinner and close in the evening, so late-night availability depends on your local store. Check the Five Guys store locator before a late drive.

Winner: Cook Out, clearly, for late-night meals.

Ordering style

Cook Out is mostly drive-thru and walk-up, and many stores run double drive-thru lanes. The menu board is long, which can feel overwhelming the first time, so our guide on how to order at Cook Out walks you through trays, styles and drinks.

Five Guys is a counter-service restaurant with seating, open kitchens and free in-shell peanuts in the dining room. Five Guys says the peanuts started as a snack to pass the time while food was cooked to order. You order at the counter or in the app, choose your toppings, and wait a few minutes for a fresh burger.

Both chains accept common card payments, and Cook Out's options, including Apple Pay, are explained in our Cook Out payment guide. If you are ordering from home, see whether Cook Out delivers.

Allergies and dietary notes

Peanut allergies are the big difference. Five Guys fries in refined peanut oil and serves peanuts in its restaurants, so anyone with a peanut allergy should read Five Guys' own allergen guide before visiting. Five Guys also says its fries contain no gluten and are cooked in fryers used only for fries, though cross-contact is always possible in a shared kitchen.

At Cook Out, check our unofficial Cook Out allergen menu and gluten-free options notes, then confirm with your store. If you are counting calories, our Cook Out calorie calculator and healthiest Cook Out options can help. Always confirm allergens with staff, because recipes and suppliers change.

Who should pick which?

Choose Cook Out if you:

Choose Five Guys if you:

Ordering tips for each

At Cook Out, start with a tray and make one side something you cannot get elsewhere, such as hush puppies, okra or a corn dog. If you want a snack on the side, the bacon wrap and cheese bites are fan favorites. Upgrade the drink to a milkshake, and try a Cook Out Style burger at least once. Our what to order at Cook Out list and the Tray Builder help you plan.

At Five Guys, order a "Little" burger if you are not very hungry, because the regular has two patties. Share a regular fries between two people, try the Cajun seasoning, and ask for grilled onions and mushrooms if you like a richer burger.

The bottom line

Cook Out vs Five Guys is really a choice between value and indulgence. Cook Out gives you a char-grilled burger, two sides, a drink or shake and late hours for a low price. Five Guys gives you a bigger, fully customized burger and famous fresh-cut fries for a higher price. Hungry at midnight on a budget? Head to Cook Out. Craving a loaded burger and a bag of fries? Five Guys is the treat.

Want more matchups? Compare Cook Out vs In-N-Out for another famous burger rival, or see the full Cook Out menu with prices.

Want a custard-shake rival instead? Read Cook Out vs Shake Shack.

See the Full Cook Out Menu

Every item, with sizes and prices by state.

View the Menu

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Cook Out cheaper than Five Guys?
Usually, yes. Cook Out's tray includes a main, two sides and a drink at a low price, while Five Guys charges more for a larger burger and fries. Our dated value check shows the gap with real receipts.
Which is better, Cook Out or Five Guys?
It depends on what you want. Five Guys is better for a big custom burger and fresh-cut fries. Cook Out is better for value, side variety, milkshake flavors and late-night hours.
Does Five Guys have more toppings than Cook Out?
Five Guys offers 15 free toppings that you combine any way you like. Cook Out uses named burger styles, such as Cook Out Style with chili, slaw, onions and mustard, and Out West with BBQ sauce, bacon and cheese.
Does Five Guys use peanut oil?
Yes. Five Guys says it fries its fries in 100% refined peanut oil, and it serves peanuts in its restaurants. People with peanut allergies should check Five Guys' allergen guide first.
Is Cook Out open later than Five Guys?
In most areas, yes. Most Cook Out locations stay open until about 3 AM, or 4 AM on weekends. Five Guys hours vary by store and most close in the evening.
Is this site affiliated with Cook Out or Five Guys?
No. This is an independent, unofficial fan guide. We are not affiliated with Cook Out or Five Guys, and prices and hours vary by location.