Cook Out vs Chick-fil-A: Which Should You Pick?
Published October 28, 2026
Quick Answer: Cook Out vs Chick-fil-A comes down to what you want and when. Chick-fil-A is a chicken specialist known for its pickle-topped chicken sandwich, nuggets, waffle fries, sauces and polished drive-thru service, but it closes every Sunday and usually by late evening. Cook Out is a cheaper all-rounder with chargrilled burgers, barbecue, chicken, hot dogs and more than 40 milkshake flavors, usually bundled into a Cook Out Tray, and most locations are open seven days a week until 3 or 4 a.m. Pick Chick-fil-A for the classic chicken sandwich and breakfast; pick Cook Out for Sundays, late nights, variety and value.
Sunday closure alone sends a lot of traffic to Cook Out in the Southeast — this section is about the other six days when both are open.
Pickle-fried chicken vs everything else
Chick-fil-A is the cleaner pick for waffle fries, nuggets, and the classic chicken sandwich with sauces. Cook Out is the pick when someone still wants a burger, BBQ, or a 40-flavor shake list on the same run.
Polished drive-thru speed often favors Chick-fil-A at lunch. Late-night variety favors Cook Out when the lane is still open.
Prices last checked July 31, 2026. May vary by location — check your local Cook Out.
Unofficial; not official Cook Out pricing. Price methodology
This site is an unofficial fan guide and is not affiliated with Cook Out or Chick-fil-A. Prices, hours and menus vary by location, so check your local store. For the full line-up, open our Cook Out menu prices.
Cook Out vs Chick-fil-A at a glance
| Cook Out | Chick-fil-A | |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | 1989, Greensboro, NC (see our history page) | Chicken chain (Chick-fil-A corporate history) |
| Known for | Cook Out Trays, chargrilled burgers, 40+ shakes | chicken sandwich, nuggets, waffle fries, sauces |
| Reach | mainly the Southeast and Mid-Atlantic | Large U.S. quick-service chain |
| Sundays | open | closed |
| Late night | often until 3 or 4 a.m. | usually closes by late evening |
| Breakfast | no breakfast menu | yes |
| Menu style | broad: burgers, BBQ, chicken, wraps, hot dogs | focused on chicken |
Origin stories
Cook Out opened its first drive-thru in Greensboro in 1989 and built a loyal following on fresh burgers, big trays and low prices. It is privately run and has expanded steadily through the South and Mid-Atlantic. Read more in our Cook Out history.
Chick-fil-A's founder, S. Truett Cathy, opened a small diner called the Dwarf Grill in Hapeville, Georgia, in 1946. That is where the original chicken sandwich was developed: a pressure-cooked, breaded boneless breast on a toasted, buttered bun with two pickle chips. The first restaurant named Chick-fil-A opened in Atlanta's Greenbriar Mall in 1967, and the first standalone restaurant followed in 1986. Chick-fil-A describes itself on its corporate site as one of the largest U.S. quick-service restaurant companies; we do not repeat location totals here.
The Sunday question
This is the biggest practical difference. Chick-fil-A has closed on Sundays since 1946, when Truett Cathy decided his team should have a day to rest, spend time with family or worship. Cook Out is open on Sundays, usually from 10:30 a.m. until about 3 a.m. If it is Sunday and you want a chicken sandwich and a milkshake, Cook Out is the obvious choice. Check our Cook Out hours page and the holiday schedule before a late run.
The chicken sandwich
At Chick-fil-A, the original chicken sandwich is the star: a juicy breaded filet, two pickles and a buttered bun, simple on purpose. There are also spicy and deluxe versions and a grilled option, plus seasonal limited-time sandwiches.
At Cook Out, you can choose a chicken sandwich, a spicy chicken sandwich, a chicken strip sandwich or one of the "style" chicken breasts, such as Cajun, cheddar, club or barbecue, which add toppings. Our chicken sandwich ranking breaks them down. The chicken strip club is a fan favorite.
Verdict: Chick-fil-A wins on the classic fried chicken sandwich. Cook Out wins on variety and toppings.
Nuggets, strips and other chicken
Chick-fil-A offers nuggets (breaded or grilled), Chick-n-Strips and wraps. Cook Out has chicken nuggets, chicken strips, Cajun chicken, wraps and a chicken quesadilla. If chicken is the whole meal, Chick-fil-A has the deeper bench. If your group also wants burgers, barbecue or hot dogs, Cook Out covers everyone.
Fries and sides
Chick-fil-A's waffle fries are famous, and its sides include mac and cheese, fruit cup and salads depending on the season.
Cook Out's sides are where it pulls ahead on choice: regular fries, Cajun fries, hush puppies, onion rings, cheese bites, coleslaw, chili, bacon wraps and more. A Cook Out Tray includes two sides, so you can try two at once.
Sauces
Chick-fil-A's sauce lineup is a big part of its appeal, led by the signature Chick-fil-A Sauce, with Polynesian, Honey Mustard and Barbeque among the regulars. Cook Out has its own set of dipping sauces and burger toppings; see our Cook Out sauces list and sauce pairing guide.
Verdict: Chick-fil-A wins on signature sauces. Cook Out wins on toppings and "style" options.
Milkshakes and drinks
Chick-fil-A serves hand-spun milkshakes in a handful of flavors, plus lemonade and frosted lemonade, and in 2026 it added Frosted Sodas and Floats to its permanent menu.
Cook Out's milkshakes are its calling card, with more than 40 flavors including fruit, candy and seasonal shakes, plus a Cheerwine float. See our milkshake ranking for the best ones.
Verdict: Cook Out wins on shake variety by a wide margin.
Value
Cook Out is known for low prices and big portions, especially the tray. A Cook Out Tray (one main, two sides and a drink) usually costs less than a comparable chicken sandwich meal at Chick-fil-A, and you can upgrade the drink to a milkshake for a small extra charge. Chick-fil-A charges more but is consistent and fast. Check current local prices on our Cook Out prices page and the value comparison.
Service and experience
Chick-fil-A is famous for polite service, a fast multi-lane drive-thru and dining rooms with play areas at many locations. Cook Out is mostly drive-thru and walk-up, with limited or no indoor seating at many stores, and lines can be long late at night in college towns. Both chains have loyal fans; the experience you prefer depends on whether you want to sit down with kids or grab a late-night tray.
Breakfast
Chick-fil-A serves breakfast every morning it is open, including the chicken biscuit and chicken minis. Cook Out does not have a breakfast menu and usually opens at 10:30 a.m. Read our Cook Out breakfast explainer for details.
Cook Out orders for Chick-fil-A fans
If you love Chick-fil-A but it is Sunday or past closing time, these Cook Out orders come closest to the experience:
- Chicken sandwich tray with Cajun fries and hush puppies. A plain fried chicken sandwich is the nearest match to the original. Ask for pickles if your store doesn't add them by default.
- Spicy chicken sandwich tray. A good stand-in for a spicy chicken sandwich, with a peppery kick.
- Chicken nuggets with a dipping sauce and fries. Simple and kid-friendly.
- Any tray plus a lemonade or a fruit milkshake. Banana pudding, strawberry or peach shakes are popular picks.
Our best Cook Out tray combinations and secret menu hacks have more ideas.
Ordering tips for each chain
At Chick-fil-A, the mobile app lets you order ahead, collect rewards and pick up at the drive-thru or counter. Lunch and dinner rushes move quickly thanks to staff taking orders outside on tablets. Remember that the app will not let you order on Sundays.
At Cook Out, most ordering happens at the drive-thru or walk-up window, so have your tray choices ready: one main, two sides and a drink. Paying a little more for a milkshake instead of a soda is the most popular upgrade. Late-night lines can be long near campuses, so give yourself extra time after midnight.
Families and groups
For a family dinner on a weekday, Chick-fil-A's dining rooms, kids' meals and play areas at many locations make it an easy choice. For a group with mixed cravings, Cook Out makes it simpler: one person can get a burger, another barbecue, another chicken, and everyone can pick a different shake. Cook Out is also the better option for groups heading out after a game, a late shift or a movie.
Which should you choose?
- Choose Chick-fil-A if you want the classic chicken sandwich, nuggets with signature sauces, breakfast, or a sit-down meal with kids on a weekday.
- Choose Cook Out if it is Sunday, late at night, your group wants burgers and chicken, you want a milkshake with dozens of flavors, or you want the most food for the money.
Comparing other chains? See Cook Out vs Popeyes, Cook Out vs Zaxby's and Cook Out vs Bojangles.