Comparisons

Cook Out vs Arby's: Roast Beef, Trays and Sides

Published November 12, 2026

Quick Answer: Cook Out vs Arby's comes down to what you want in the sandwich and what you want on the side. Cook Out is a regional late-night tray stop with burgers, char-grilled chicken, a long sides list and about 39 milkshake flavors. Arby's is a national sandwich chain known for roast beef, the Beef ’n Cheddar, curly fries and Jamocha shakes.

Cook Out vs Arby's meal comparison: a roast beef sandwich with melted cheddar and curly fries on a white plate, with a cheeseburger and a plain cup nearby, no logos or text

If you are deciding at a highway exit where only one brand is lit up, roast beef versus a tray is a protein choice more than a price contest.

When roast beef beats a tray

Arby’s wins when someone wants thin-sliced roast beef, curly fries as the default side, or a Jamocha shake as the main event. Cook Out wins when the car wants two different sides on one ticket, a char-grilled burger, or a milkshake flavor the other chain does not list.

Late night, Cook Out’s lane is often built for trays and shakes. Arby’s is a better fit for a focused sandwich run — not a full mixed feast.

Prices last checked July 31, 2026. May vary by location — check your local Cook Out.

Unofficial; not official Cook Out pricing. Price methodology

This site is an unofficial fan guide and is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Cook Out or Arby's. Brand names are used only to identify each restaurant. Prices and menus vary by location.

Cook Out vs Arby's at a glance

Cook OutArby's
Founded1989, Greensboro, NC (see our history page)U.S. chain since 1964 (Arby’s corporate history)
SizeRegional Southeast U.S. chain (sourced counts on our history page)A national chain with locations in many U.S. states
Main focusBurgers, char-grilled chicken, hot dogs, barbecue, shakesRoast beef and other sandwiches, curly fries, shakes
Signature dealThe Tray: one main, two sides, a drinkCombos built around a sandwich, a side and a drink
Signature itemsStyle burgers, trays, about 39 milkshake flavorsRoast beef, Beef ’n Cheddar, curly fries, Jamocha shakes
SidesA long mix-and-match listCurly fries plus a shorter set of sides
DessertAbout 39 milkshake flavorsShakes, including Jamocha, on a shorter list
OrderingMostly drive-thru, often open lateDining room and drive-thru at most locations; hours vary

Arby’s markets itself as a roast-beef sandwich chain. Founding details appear on Arby’s corporate history pages; we do not duplicate them here.

The sandwiches

Cook Out

Cook Out’s mains are burgers and char-grilled chicken, plus hot dogs and barbecue. Burgers are ordered in styles — Barbecue, Cajun, Cheddar, Club, Homemade and others — so the toppings change more often than the patty itself. Chicken sandwiches usually start with a grilled breast. None of that is roast beef, and you should not go to Cook Out expecting an Arby’s-style sliced beef sandwich.

The usual way to order is the Tray: one main, two sides, a drink. Details and current figures are on Tray combos and in the tray builder. How to order at Cook Out walks through the board if you are new to it.

Arby's

Arby's built its name on roast beef. The classic is thinly sliced beef on a bun; the Beef ’n Cheddar adds cheese and a red sauce on a different bun. The chain’s long-running slogan is “We Have The Meats,” and the menu also includes other sandwiches that vary by time and place. Curly fries are the side most people associate with the brand, and Jamocha — a coffee-and-chocolate shake — is the dessert most people can name.

We do not list Arby's prices here. There is no single national board we can verify the way we can verify a Cook Out Southeast tray price.

Which sandwich wins?

If you want roast beef, Arby's wins without a contest. If you want a grilled burger or chicken sandwich you can pair with two different sides, Cook Out wins on format. They are not the same kind of sandwich stop, even though both are quick, informal, and easy to eat in a car.

Sides

Sides are a real difference.

Cook Out’s sides list is long and is meant to be mixed on a Tray: fries, onion rings, slaw, hushpuppies, Cajun rice and other options depending on the board. You pick two, and that choice is part of the meal, not an afterthought. Our sides ranked list and the sides menu cover what we track.

Arby's is known for curly fries. Other sides appear on the menu, but the brand’s side identity is narrower than Cook Out’s tray list. If curly fries are the thing you showed up for, Arby's is the obvious pick. If you want two different sides in one order, Cook Out is set up for that.

Milkshakes

Cook Out treats shakes as a headline, with about 39 flavors and a common Tray upgrade from drink to shake. Arby's has shakes, and Jamocha is a signature, but the list is much shorter. A Jamocha fan may still prefer Arby's. Someone who wants to choose among dozens of flavors will be happier at Cook Out.

Value and hours

On our July 2026 Southeast board check, a Cook Out Regular Tray was about $7.39 and a Jr. Tray about $6.39 (Regular Trays ran about $6.29 to $7.99 depending on the state), including one main, two sides and a drink. A shake upgrade was about $1.60 on that same check. Those figures are as of that July 2026 check; see current prices before you go.

Arby's combo prices vary by location. Compare the sandwich combo you would actually buy with a Tray, rather than assuming one chain is always cheaper.

Hours also differ in emphasis. Cook Out is known for late drive-thru service; check our hours page for the pattern and for holiday notes, then confirm the store. Arby's hours vary and are often not as late as a typical Cook Out, but some locations may stay open later than others. Use an official Arby's locator for the restaurant you have in mind. We do not invent closing times.

Where you will find them

Cook Out began in Greensboro in 1989; sourced store counts are on our history page. Arby's is a national chain. If you are outside Cook Out country, this comparison is usually theoretical: Arby's is the one you can drive to.

Best first orders

If you want the Cook Out experience: a Regular Tray with a style burger or grilled chicken, two sides you actually want, and a shake upgrade.

If you want the Arby's experience: a roast beef sandwich or a Beef ’n Cheddar with curly fries, and a Jamocha if you like coffee-chocolate shakes.

If the car is split: Cook Out can cover a burger person and a chicken person. It cannot cover a roast-beef person. In a mixed group that includes roast beef, you may be choosing the majority or making two stops.

Sauces and customizing

Cook Out leans on burger and chicken "styles," so toppings and sauces are built into the name of the sandwich. You can still ask for changes, but the board is organized around those styles rather than a long add-on list. Arby's sandwiches come with a more fixed set of toppings — cheese and sauce on a Beef ’n Cheddar, for example — and you customize from that starting point. Neither chain is a build-it-from-zero burger counter.

If you have a preferred sauce, check the board or the official app at the store you visit rather than assuming a topping travels from one chain to the other. Cook Out styles and Arby's sandwiches do not share a sauce language.

The verdict

Choose Cook Out when you are in its 11-state footprint and you want a grilled main, two sides and a long shake list, especially late at night. Choose Arby's when you want roast beef, curly fries or a Jamocha shake, or when there is no Cook Out nearby.

For other comparisons, see Cook Out vs Taco Bell and Cook Out vs Raising Cane’s. Always confirm items, prices and hours at the restaurant you visit. This guide is unofficial and is not affiliated with either chain.

See the Full Cook Out Menu

Every item, with sizes and prices by state.

View the Menu

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Cook Out have roast beef like Arby's?
Roast beef is not a Cook Out signature. Cook Out is built around burgers, char-grilled chicken, hot dogs, barbecue, sides and milkshakes. If a roast beef sandwich is the reason for the trip, Arby's is the more direct choice.
Which has better sides, Cook Out or Arby's?
Cook Out offers a long mix-and-match sides list that you can put on a Tray. Arby's is known for curly fries, plus other sides that vary by location. If variety is the goal, Cook Out has more tray-side options; if curly fries are the goal, Arby's is the usual pick. See our Cook Out sides ranked list for the Cook Out side of that comparison.
Is Cook Out or Arby's open later?
Cook Out is known for late drive-thru hours in the states where it operates. Arby's hours vary by location and are often earlier than a late-night Cook Out, but that is not a rule for every store. Check Cook Out hours on this site and an Arby's locator for the restaurant you plan to visit.
How does a Cook Out Tray compare to an Arby's combo?
A Cook Out Tray includes one main, two sides and a drink. On our July 2026 Southeast board check, a Regular Tray was about $7.39. Arby's combo prices vary by location, and we do not list a national Arby's price here. Compare the specific combo you would order with a Tray.
Does Arby's have milkshakes?
Arby's is known for Jamocha and other shakes, but the shake list is much shorter than Cook Out’s about 39 flavors. If a long shake menu is the point of the stop, Cook Out is the clearer match.
Is this an official comparison?
No. This site is an unofficial fan guide and is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Cook Out or Arby's. Brand names are used only to identify each restaurant. Confirm current items and hours with the restaurant you visit.