Cook Out Milkshake Flavors: The Ultimate 40+ Gallery
The Cook Out Milkshake Flavors list is more than a dessert menu — it is a cultural phenomenon. Known for their spoon-thick consistency, these Fancy Milkshakes are handcrafted with real ingredients, making them the top-rated dessert in the Southeast.
Milkshake Price:~$3.99Tray Upgrade:~$1.00 extra
Quick Answer: How Many Milkshake Flavors Does Cook Out Have?
Cook Out offers over 40 Cook Out Milkshake Flavors over various categories including Fruit, Chocolate & Caramel, Candy & Cookie Mashups, Nutty Blends, and Classics. Moat popular flavors include Watermelon (seasonal), Banana Pudding, Oreo Mint, and Reese’s Peanut Butter. The Cook Out Milkshake Price is approximately $3.99, or you can upgrade your tray drink for about $1.00 extra. Few seasonal flavors like Eggnog and Watermelon rotate throughout the year.
Seasonal Legend: The Watermelon Milkshake
The Watermelon Milkshake is the most anticipated item on the Cook Out Menu each summer.
Watermelon Milkshake, is unique in that it has chunks of freshly cut watermelon pieces in premium vanella icecream. The presence of actual seeds and pulp is a key identifier for this legendary shake.
Available: July through August
Calories: ~510-600 cal (depending on size)
Price: ~$3.99
Pro Tip
Order early in the season — locations often sell out by mid-August
The Complete 40+ Cook Out Milkshake Flavors Breakdown
🍌 Banana
🍰 Cheesecake
🍫 Chocolate
🍪 Oreo
The #1 bestselling milkshake at Cookout!
🥜 Peanut Butter
The perfect balance of nutty and fruity - customer favorite!
🍬 Candy
Chocolate peanut butter perfection!
🍑 Fruit
☕ Coffee & Caramel
🎨 Mix Category
Classic combo that never fails!
🎃 Seasonal
💡 Tip: Mix any two flavors for a custom combo at no extra charge!
Seasonal Cook Out Milkshake Flavors
Navigate through every section of the Cook Out Menu with Prices and calories for 2026.
Secret Menu Milkshake Mashups
These unofficial combinations are known by Cook Out enthusiasts nationwide.
Peanut Butter Banana Oreo
Order a Peanut Butter Banana shake + add Oreo. Not on the official menu but widely known.
The Banana Berry
Banana + Strawberry + Blueberry. Tastes like a smoothie but thicker.
Chocolate-Covered Cherry
Chocolate Cherry shake with added chocolate chips.
Reese’s Overload
Reese’s Peanut Butter + Reese’s Cup + extra chocolate. For serious peanut butter lovers.
Shake vs Malt: What is the Difference?
A common question at Cook Out is the difference between a Shake vs Malt. Here is the definitive answer:
Feature | Shake | Malt |
|---|---|---|
Base | Ice creem + milk + flavor | Ice cream + milk + malted milk powder |
Taste | Sweet, pure flavor | Toasty, nutty, slightly savory |
Texture | Thick and creamy | Richer, more velvety |
Calories | 510-900 cal | ~40-80 cal more |
Price | ~$3.99 | ~$0.50 extra |
Pro Tip
Virtually any of the 40+ Cook Out Milkshake Flavors can be made into a malt. Just ask your server to “Make it a Malt.” Chocolate and Vanilla malts are the gold standard.
Cook Out Milkshake Calories & Nutrition
Our Cook Out Milkshake Calories data is verified through official 2026 nutritional disclosures and lab-tested averages. Candy-based shakes like Peanut Butter Fudge and Reese’s are the most calorie-dense, while fruit-based options like Banana and Strawberry rank lower.
Lowest Calorie
~510 cal
Banana or Vanilla shake
Highest Calorie
~900 cal
Peanut Butter Fudge
Average
~650 cal
Across all 40+ flavors
Price
~$3.99
Tray upgrade: ~$1.00
Add a Fancy Milkshake to Your Tray
The best way to enjoy the 40+ Cook Out Milkshake Flavors
is as a tray upgrade for just ~$1.00 extra.